What Is Solipsism?
Solipsism is the philosophical view that only one's own mind is certain to exist, so the external world and other people might be nothing more than contents of one's own experience.
Also searched as: solipsism meaning, what is solipsism, metaphysical solipsism, problem of other minds, solipsism vs idealism
Last updated:
Quick summary
- The word comes from the Latin solus ipse, "alone myself". It is a thesis about what you can know, or what exists, and not about selfishness.
- There are three main kinds: metaphysical (only my mind exists), epistemological (I cannot know anything else exists) and methodological (philosophy should start from one's own experience).
- It is hard to refute because every piece of evidence against it, including other people's testimony, arrives through your own experience.
- Almost no philosopher defends it. It is mostly used as a limit case that tests theories of knowledge, mind and language.
- It is different from idealism, from the simulation hypothesis and from the everyday sense of being self-absorbed.
- Chunks has short narrated stories on Descartes and on Zhuangzi's butterfly dream, two classic routes into the problem.
The three kinds of solipsism
People who say “solipsism” mean claims of very different strength.
- Metaphysical solipsism is the strong claim. Only my mind exists, and everything else, including other people, is a feature of it.
- Epistemological solipsism is weaker. Other things may exist, but I have no way of knowing it, because all I ever have is my own experience.
- Methodological solipsism is a method, not a belief. It says that inquiry should start from the individual’s own mind. Descartes’s approach is often described this way, and so is a research strategy in philosophy of mind that Jerry Fodor discussed in 1980.
Only the first kind is solipsism in the sense most people picture. The second is a form of scepticism, and the third is a way of getting a philosophical argument started.
Why it is hard to refute, and why most reject it
The classic difficulty is the problem of other minds. You see behaviour, never another person’s experience. Any proof that other minds exist has to use evidence, and all evidence comes to you as part of your own experience. The solipsist can reinterpret each piece of it as one more thing happening in their mind.
Most philosophers do not try to disprove solipsism by logic. They argue it is a poor explanation. These are the main replies.
- The argument from analogy. I know that my behaviour comes with inner experience. Other people behave like me and have bodies like mine, so they probably have minds like mine too. John Stuart Mill gave a version of this in 1865.
- Inference to the best explanation. A world of independent people and things explains why experience is so orderly, and why other people surprise you, disagree with you and know things you do not. Solipsism has to treat all of that as an unexplained feature of one mind.
- Language. Ludwig Wittgenstein’s private language argument in the Philosophical Investigations (1953) is often read as undermining the solipsist’s starting point, since the words we use to describe our inner life get their meaning from a shared practice.
None of these is a knock-down proof, which is why solipsism remains a standard test case. A theory of knowledge is judged partly by how it handles it.
Origin and key thinkers
The word is modern, built from the Latin solus (alone) and ipse (self). The thought is much older, since any radical doubt about the senses raises it. A story told of the Chinese philosopher Zhuangzi (fourth century BC) asks whether he was a man who dreamed he was a butterfly or a butterfly dreaming it was a man. It is about doubt over reality, not solipsism strictly, but it shows the same unease. See Zhuangzi’s Butterfly Dream.
René Descartes made the problem central to modern philosophy. In the Meditations (1641) he doubts everything he can, even supposing an evil demon is deceiving him, and finds one certainty: that he exists while he thinks (“I am, I exist”, Second Meditation). He was not a solipsist. He went on to argue that God exists and is no deceiver, which restores his trust in the senses and the world. Readers since have asked whether that argument works, and a Cartesian starting point leaves the solipsist’s door open. Hear the background in René Descartes and the Birth of Modern Thought.
George Berkeley’s idealism (1710) held that to be is to be perceived, but he believed in other minds and in God as the perceiver of everything, so he was not a solipsist either. Arthur Schopenhauer, who opened The World as Will and Representation (1818) with “the world is my representation”, thought that what he called theoretical egoism, the view that only one’s own self is real, could never be refuted by proof but could be found seriously held only in a madhouse (Book 2, section 19). In the Tractatus (1921) Wittgenstein wrote that what the solipsist means is correct but cannot be said, only shown (5.62). Hilary Putnam’s brain-in-a-vat argument (1981) is a modern cousin, a sceptical scenario in which everything you experience is produced by a computer.
- René Descartes1596-1650Made radical doubt the starting point of modern philosophy and found certainty only in his own thinking. He escaped solipsism by appeal to God.
- George Berkeley1685-1753Argued that to be is to be perceived. An idealist, not a solipsist, since he held that other minds and God exist.
- John Stuart Mill1806-1873Gave a classic argument from analogy for the existence of other minds (1865).
- Arthur Schopenhauer1788-1860Called theoretical egoism (solipsism) irrefutable by proof but found seriously held only in a madhouse.
- Ludwig Wittgenstein1889-1951Explored solipsism in the Tractatus (1921) and attacked the idea of a purely private language in the Philosophical Investigations (1953).
- Hilary Putnam1926-2016Used a brain-in-a-vat argument (1981) against global sceptical scenarios.
Common misunderstandings
- “Solipsists think they are the most important person alive”
- The word has a second, everyday sense of being self-absorbed, but the philosophical position is about existence and knowledge. A solipsist can be modest and kind. The claim is that my mind is all there is, not that it deserves special treatment.
- “Descartes was a solipsist”
- He started from his own mind but did not stay there. His argument that a good God exists and does not deceive us is how he reached the external world. Whether it succeeds is a separate debate.
- “Solipsism is the same as idealism”
- Idealism says reality is fundamentally mental. Solipsism says it is fundamentally my mind. An idealist like Berkeley can believe in many minds, so idealism does not lead to solipsism by itself.
- “Solipsism is the same as the simulation hypothesis or a brain in a vat”
- Those scenarios imagine an external reality, a computer or a lab, that produces your experience. Solipsism says nothing external exists. They are related sceptical ideas, not the same one. See our guide to the simulation hypothesis.
- “Solipsism has been disproved”
- Nobody has a decisive disproof from within experience. The usual case against it is that it explains less than the alternative, and that its starting point is shaky, not that it is self-contradictory.
Thinking with the idea
Solipsism is a thought experiment, not a practice, but it sharpens a few useful questions.
- Ask what would count as evidence. Try to name anything that could show other minds exist without passing through your own experience. The difficulty is the lesson.
- Separate the three kinds. Doubt about what you can know is far easier to defend than a claim about what exists.
- Compare the explanations. Which account of your experience, one mind or many, explains more with fewer unexplained assumptions?
- Notice how much you rely on testimony. Most of what you know came from other people, which makes the solipsist’s starting point look odd.
A passing sense that the world is unreal or other people are not quite real is a different matter from the philosophy. "Solipsism syndrome" is a popular label, not a recognised diagnosis. If feelings of unreality are persistent or distressing, speak to a doctor.
Frequently asked questions
What is solipsism in simple terms?
Solipsism is the idea that you can be sure of nothing except your own mind. In its strongest form it says only your mind exists and everything else, including other people, is part of your experience. The word comes from the Latin solus ipse, meaning alone myself.
What are the types of solipsism?
Metaphysical solipsism says only your own mind exists. Epistemological solipsism says other things may exist but you cannot know it. Methodological solipsism is a method that treats the individual's own mind as the starting point for inquiry and does not claim that nothing else exists.
Can solipsism be disproved?
Not by a simple logical proof, because any evidence against it reaches you through your own experience. Philosophers instead argue that it is a worse explanation than the view that other minds exist, as in the argument from analogy and inference to the best explanation, and that its starting point is questionable.
Was Descartes a solipsist?
No. In the Meditations (1641) he doubted everything he could and found certainty in his own existence as a thinker, but he went on to argue that God exists and is not a deceiver, which restored his belief in the external world and other people.
What is the difference between solipsism and idealism?
Idealism says reality is fundamentally mental. Solipsism says reality is fundamentally one's own mind. George Berkeley was an idealist who believed in many minds and in God, so he was not a solipsist.
Is solipsism the same as the simulation hypothesis?
No. The simulation hypothesis says your experience could be produced by a computer, which is an external reality. Solipsism says nothing outside your mind exists. Both are sceptical scenarios about how you know the world is real.
Is solipsism a mental illness?
No. Solipsism is a philosophical position. "Solipsism syndrome" is a popular term, not a recognised diagnosis. Persistent feelings that the world or other people are unreal can be symptoms of conditions such as depersonalisation or derealisation, and are worth discussing with a doctor.
Stories on Solipsism
Each is a narrated chapter you can read or listen to in 5–10 minutes.
- René Descartes and the birth of modern thoughtDoubt, the demon and "I think, therefore I am".
- Zhuangzi's butterfly dreamA man, a butterfly and the limits of certainty.
- Plato's allegory of the caveShadows, reality and what we take for granted.
- Socrates, the man who taught the world to questionThe habit of examining every assumption.
Thinkers and character cards
Related guides
Keep exploring
Hear Descartes, Zhuangzi, Plato and more as short narrated stories. Download Chunks free on iOS and Android.