What Is Hedonism?
Hedonism is the view that pleasure is the only thing that is good in itself, so a good life is one with as much pleasure, and as little pain, as possible.
Also searched as: hedonism meaning, what is hedonism, ethical hedonism, psychological hedonism, paradox of hedonism
Last updated:
Quick summary
- The word comes from the Greek hedone, meaning pleasure. In philosophy it names a family of views, and it is not the same as indulgence.
- Psychological hedonism is a claim about motivation: we always act to get pleasure or avoid pain. Ethical (or value) hedonism is a claim about what is good: only pleasure is.
- The main historical versions are the Cyrenaics (immediate pleasure), Epicurus (lasting peace of mind), and the utilitarians Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill (the most pleasure for the most people).
- Epicurus, who is often called a hedonist, taught simple living and friendship. He is the opposite of the party caricature.
- Standard objections include Robert Nozick's experience machine, the paradox of hedonism and hedonic adaptation.
- Chunks has short narrated stories on Epicurus and on utilitarianism if you would rather hear how these ideas began.
The main types of hedonism
Two different questions hide under one word, and it helps to keep them apart.
- Psychological hedonism says people only ever act in order to gain pleasure or avoid pain. It describes how we are built. Many philosophers reject it, and Joseph Butler argued in 1726 that we often want things, such as a friend’s success, for their own sake, with pleasure following as a result.
- Ethical or value hedonism says pleasure is the only thing good in itself and pain the only thing bad in itself. It describes what we ought to aim for.
- Egoistic hedonism says each person should pursue their own pleasure. Universalistic hedonism says to aim at the pleasure of everyone affected. Utilitarianism is the best-known universalistic version, and the two have quite different moral consequences.
Versions also differ on what pleasure is. Some stress intense physical pleasures. Others, such as Epicurus, count calm and the absence of pain as the highest pleasure. Mill argued that pleasures differ in quality as well as quantity.
Objections: the experience machine, the paradox and adaptation
Hedonism is simple and attractive, which is why philosophers have tested it hard. Three objections come up most.
- The experience machine. In Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974) Robert Nozick asked whether you would plug into a machine that gave you any pleasant experiences you liked, for life, without any of them being real. Most people say no, which suggests that we care about doing and being things, not only about how things feel.
- The paradox of hedonism. Henry Sidgwick, in The Methods of Ethics (1874), observed that aiming directly at pleasure often defeats itself, which he called the “fundamental paradox of egoistic hedonism”. The people who are happiest tend to be absorbed in something else, such as work, people or a cause.
- Hedonic adaptation. Psychologists Philip Brickman and Donald Campbell described the “hedonic treadmill” in 1971: we get used to improvements and drift back towards a baseline, so chasing the next pleasure does not add up.
Defenders reply that sophisticated hedonism already accounts for this. Epicurus recommended modest desires for exactly this reason, and Mill’s higher pleasures were meant to answer the charge that hedonism is only fit for pigs.
Origin and key thinkers
The Cyrenaic school, founded by Aristippus of Cyrene, a pupil of Socrates, is usually taken as the earliest explicit hedonism. The Cyrenaics held that pleasure is the good and that the best pleasures are immediate and bodily. They kept the present in view and gave little weight to the future.
Epicurus (341-270 BC) accepted that pleasure is the good but disagreed about what pleasure is. For him the highest pleasure is freedom from physical pain (aponia) and mental disturbance (ataraxia). In the Letter to Menoeceus he stresses that he does not mean the pleasures of the self-indulgent, and that the pleasant life depends on sober reasoning, modest wants and friendship. See our page on Epicureanism, or hear Epicurus and the Philosophy of Pleasure.
Modern hedonism took a social turn. Jeremy Bentham opened An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (1789) by saying that nature has put humankind under two sovereign masters, pain and pleasure. He proposed to measure pleasure and add it up across everyone. John Stuart Mill, in Utilitarianism (1861), argued that intellectual and moral pleasures count for more than mere sensation, and wrote that it is better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied. Both are covered in utilitarianism. The idea also lives on in the “hedonic psychology” of Daniel Kahneman, Ed Diener and Norbert Schwarz, who edited a major collection on it in 1999.
- Aristippus of Cyrene5th-4th century BCPupil of Socrates and founder of the Cyrenaic school, which held that immediate bodily pleasure is the good.
- Epicurus341-270 BCTaught that the highest pleasure is freedom from pain and anxiety, reached through modest desires, study and friendship.
- Jeremy Bentham1748-1832Founder of modern utilitarianism, a universalistic hedonism that tries to measure pleasure and pain and add them across people.
- John Stuart Mill1806-1873Refined Bentham by distinguishing higher and lower pleasures in Utilitarianism (1861).
- Henry Sidgwick1838-1900Defended hedonism with great care in The Methods of Ethics (1874), where he discussed what he called the fundamental paradox of egoistic hedonism.
- Robert Nozick1938-2002Proposed the experience machine in Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974) as an objection to hedonism.
Common misunderstandings
- “Hedonism means partying and self-indulgence”
- That is the everyday sense. As a philosophy, hedonism only says pleasure is the good, and the most careful hedonists argued that a pleasant life needs restraint. Epicurus lived simply and warned that some pleasures cost more pain than they are worth.
- “Epicurus taught "eat, drink and be merry"”
- The slogan sounds Epicurean but is not his. Similar lines appear in the Bible (Ecclesiastes 8:15, Isaiah 22:13 and Luke 12:19). Epicurus wrote in the Letter to Menoeceus that the pleasant life is not made by feasting and revelry, but by sober reasoning.
- “Hedonists only care about themselves”
- Egoistic hedonists do, but universalistic hedonists, including Bentham and Mill, say everyone’s pleasure counts equally. Utilitarianism is hedonism with a very wide circle of concern.
- “Psychological hedonism has been proved: everyone is secretly after pleasure”
- It is a contested theory. Critics note that you can only get pleasure from something you already want for its own sake, so desire for the thing comes first. Calling every motive “pleasure-seeking” risks making the claim true by definition, which makes it empty.
Using the idea
You do not have to accept hedonism to use its better insights about a good life. These are the ones that survive the objections.
- Count the whole cost. Epicurus’s test was to ask what a pleasure will cost you afterwards. A pleasure with a hangover attached is a poor trade.
- Favour pleasures that last. Friendship, study, good food in company and a quiet mind outlast a purchase. Hedonic adaptation fades the second kind faster.
- Do not aim at pleasure directly. Sidgwick’s paradox suggests pleasure often arrives as a by-product of absorbing activity. Choose the activity.
- Ask Nozick’s question. If you would not plug in to a machine that guarantees pleasant experiences, work out what else you value and make room for it.
If you are using pleasure-seeking to escape low mood, anxiety or a habit that has become hard to control, speak to a doctor or a mental health professional.
Frequently asked questions
What is hedonism in simple terms?
Hedonism is the view that pleasure is the highest good, and pain the greatest evil. A life goes well, on this view, to the extent that it contains pleasure and avoids pain. The word comes from the Greek hedone, meaning pleasure.
What is the difference between ethical hedonism and psychological hedonism?
Psychological hedonism is a claim about motivation: that people always act to get pleasure or avoid pain. Ethical hedonism, also called value hedonism, is a claim about what is good: that pleasure is the only thing good in itself. You can accept one without the other.
Was Epicurus a hedonist?
Yes, in the philosophical sense: he held that pleasure is the highest good. But he defined the greatest pleasure as freedom from physical pain and mental disturbance, and recommended simple living, study and friendship. His view is far from the popular image of hedonism as indulgence.
Is utilitarianism a form of hedonism?
Classical utilitarianism, as held by Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill, is a universalistic hedonism: it says the right act produces the most pleasure and least pain for everyone affected. Some modern utilitarians define wellbeing differently and are not hedonists.
What is the paradox of hedonism?
It is the observation, discussed by Henry Sidgwick in The Methods of Ethics (1874) as the "fundamental paradox of egoistic hedonism", that aiming directly at pleasure tends to defeat itself. Pleasure is more often a by-product of being absorbed in activities, people or causes than something you reach by chasing it.
What is Nozick's experience machine?
In Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974), Robert Nozick imagined a machine that could give you any experiences you wanted for life, with none of them real. Because many people would refuse to plug in, he argued that we value more than pleasant experience, which counts against hedonism.
What is hedonic adaptation?
It is the tendency to return to a baseline level of happiness after good or bad events. Philip Brickman and Donald Campbell called it the hedonic treadmill in 1971. It is often cited as a reason that chasing more pleasure does not make people lastingly happier.
Stories on Hedonism
Each is a narrated chapter you can read or listen to in 5–10 minutes.
- Epicurus and the philosophy of pleasureHow the school of the Garden was caricatured.
- Utilitarianism: the greatest goodBentham, Mill and the arithmetic of happiness.
- Socrates, the man who taught the world to questionThe teacher of Aristippus, Plato and many others.
- Aristotle and the pursuit of virtueA rival picture of the good life.
Thinkers and character cards
Related guides
Keep exploring
Hear Epicurus, the utilitarians and more as short narrated stories. Download Chunks free on iOS and Android.