Skip to content

Utilitarianism: The Greatest Good

Bentham's felicific calculus weighed pleasure and pain by seven factors, and the theory still shapes how charity is judged.

Chapter 1

A Sentence in Dublin

0:56

Utilitarianism is a simple claim about right and wrong. The right action is the one that produces the most happiness for everyone it affects. Not the action that pleases God, or follows tradition, or helps you. The phrase came from Francis Hutcheson, an Ulster-Scots philosopher who would later serve as a professor of moral philosophy at the University of Glasgow. In 1725 he was living in Dublin and running an academy when he wrote that 'that Action is best, which procures the greatest Happiness for the greatest Numbers.' He was arguing against Thomas Hobbes, who held that people are driven by self-interest. Hutcheson thought we have an innate moral sense, and that it leads us to judge actions by their results. But Hutcheson left a hard question open. If happiness is the measure, can anyone actually measure it?

Frequently Asked Questions

What does utilitarianism actually claim?

Utilitarianism claims that the right action is the one that produces the most happiness for everyone affected. It judges actions by their results rather than by tradition, religious rules or self-interest. Everyone's happiness counts equally.

How did Mill change Bentham's version of utilitarianism?

Mill argued that some pleasures are higher than others, so intellectual and moral satisfaction outranks mere physical pleasure. He said competent judges who have experienced both kinds consistently prefer the higher ones. He also treated individual liberty as a necessary condition for the greatest general happiness.

What is the Transplant objection and how do rule utilitarians reply?

In the Transplant case, a surgeon could save five dying patients by killing one healthy person for organs, and a simple count of outcomes seems to approve it. Rule utilitarians reply that we should follow general rules such as 'do not kill patients,' because those rules produce the most happiness in the long run.

Learn more

To continue the story, download the Chunks Microlearning app

Or get it straight away: