Skip to content

What Is Utilitarianism?

Utilitarianism is the ethical theory that the right action is the one that produces the most overall wellbeing, counting everyone affected equally.

Also searched as: utilitarianism meaning, greatest happiness principle, Bentham and Mill, act vs rule utilitarianism

Last updated:

Quick summary

  • It is a consequentialist theory: an action is judged by its results, not by the motive or the rule behind it.
  • Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832) founded the modern version; John Stuart Mill (1806-1873) refined it.
  • Everyone's wellbeing counts the same, whoever they are and wherever they live.
  • Act utilitarianism judges each action; rule utilitarianism judges the rules that tend to produce the best results.
  • The main objections are that it can seem to justify harming individuals for the majority, that wellbeing is hard to measure, and that it demands a great deal.
  • It shapes real policy, from cost-benefit analysis to health rationing and effective altruism.

The core idea: maximise overall wellbeing

Utilitarianism starts from a claim about what matters: the experiences of beings who can feel good or bad. Pain and suffering are bad, pleasure and happiness are good, and morality is about making things go as well as possible. To decide what to do, you compare the likely consequences of your options for everyone affected and choose the one with the best total outcome.

Three features give the theory its character. It is consequentialist, so a good outcome can justify an action that would otherwise look doubtful. It is impartial, so your own happiness counts for no more than a stranger’s. And it is aggregative, so wellbeing adds up across people. Bentham used the phrase “the greatest happiness of the greatest number” early, in his Fragment on Government(1776), but later preferred “the greatest happiness principle” or the “principle of utility”. The phrase had earlier roots: the Scottish philosopher Francis Hutcheson used something very close in 1725.

There are two main versions. Act utilitarianism asks of each choice, what would do the most good here and now? Rule utilitarianism asks which general rules, if people followed them, would do the most good, and then follows those rules even when breaking one looks better in a single case. Rules such as “keep promises” and “do not punish the innocent” do well on this test, which is how rule utilitarians answer many standard objections.

Origin and key thinkers

Bentham, an English jurist and reformer, set out the “principle of utility” in An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (printed in 1780, published in 1789). He wanted a test that could be used to judge laws and institutions, and he proposed a “felicific calculus” that rated pleasures and pains by factors including intensity, duration, certainty, nearness, fruitfulness, purity and extent, meaning how many people they affect. He also argued that the suffering of animals counts, and campaigned for reforms in law and prisons.

John Stuart Mill, raised by his father to be Bentham’s intellectual heir, published Utilitarianism, serialised in Fraser’s Magazine in 1861 and issued as a book in 1863. He broke with Bentham by arguing that pleasures differ in quality as well as amount, writing that it is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied, and better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied. Mill also stressed individual liberty and the equality of women in other works, and he argued that rules protecting rights tend to serve overall wellbeing.

Henry Sidgwick gave the theory its most rigorous statement in The Methods of Ethics (1874). In the twentieth century the debate shifted to preference utilitarianism (R. M. Hare, then Peter Singer), which counts satisfied preferences rather than pleasure. Singer’s 1972 essay “Famine, Affluence and Morality” and his later work helped launch effective altruism. The theory also lies behind the trolley problem, the thought experiment that Philippa Foot devised in 1967 for a discussion of the doctrine of double effect. Philosophers now use it to test utilitarian and rival intuitions about where consequences should and should not win.

  • Jeremy Bentham1748-1832Founded modern utilitarianism and proposed measuring wellbeing as a basis for law and policy.
  • John Stuart Mill1806-1873Refined the theory with the idea that pleasures differ in quality, and tied it to liberty and individual rights.
  • Henry Sidgwick1838-1900Gave the most systematic nineteenth-century defence in The Methods of Ethics (1874).
  • Peter Singerborn 1946Applied preference utilitarianism to animals and global poverty, and influenced effective altruism.
  • Philippa Foot1920-2010Devised the trolley case in 1967 in a discussion of the doctrine of double effect; the name "trolley problem" came later with Judith Jarvis Thomson.

Common misunderstandings

“Utilitarianism says the ends justify any means”
A careful utilitarian counts every consequence, including damage to trust, the fear created by a harsh precedent and the loss of rights. Many philosophers argue that a reasoned utilitarianism rarely permits the cruel acts critics cite, though critics reply that the theory still allows them in principle.
“It only means maximising pleasure, like hedonism”
Bentham focused on pleasure and pain, but later utilitarians count preferences, interests or wellbeing more broadly. Mill ranked intellectual and moral pleasures above bodily ones.
“Utilitarians ignore minorities because the majority wins”
The theory asks for total wellbeing, not a vote. A small group suffering severely can outweigh a large group gaining slightly. Even so, philosophers such as John Rawls argued that it does not take the separateness of persons seriously enough, which remains one of the main objections.
“Utilitarianism and Epicureanism are the same”
Both value pleasure, but Epicurus asked what makes one person’s life go well and advised a retired life among friends. Utilitarianism asks what a moral agent should do about everyone’s wellbeing. See Epicureanism.

Where utilitarian reasoning shows up

Few people are strict utilitarians, but the way of thinking is a standard tool, and you can use it to check a decision.

  1. List who is affected. Include people who are easy to forget: those downstream, those who cannot speak for themselves and those in the future.
  2. Estimate the size and likelihood of benefits and harms. A modest gain for thousands can outweigh a large gain for one person. Say which numbers you are guessing.
  3. Compare the options, including doing nothing. The question is which option does most good, not whether a plan is good in isolation.
  4. Test the rule, not just the case. Ask what would happen if everyone in your position did this. This is the rule utilitarian check, and it catches many bad shortcuts.
  5. Check against rights and fairness. If the answer feels deeply wrong, treat that as evidence. It may reveal a consequence you missed or a limit that the theory does not capture.

Real examples include public health bodies that use quality-adjusted life years to compare treatments, cost-benefit analysis in transport and environmental policy, and charities that rank projects by lives improved per pound or dollar.

Frequently asked questions

What is utilitarianism in simple terms?

Utilitarianism is the idea that the right thing to do is whatever produces the most overall wellbeing, counting everyone equally. It judges actions by their consequences, so you compare the outcomes of your options and pick the best.

Who founded utilitarianism?

Jeremy Bentham is usually credited as the founder of modern utilitarianism, in his Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (1789). John Stuart Mill refined it in Utilitarianism (serialised 1861, published as a book in 1863). Earlier thinkers such as Francis Hutcheson had used similar phrases.

What is the difference between act and rule utilitarianism?

Act utilitarianism judges each action by whether it produces the best result in that case. Rule utilitarianism judges which general rules would produce the best results if widely followed, and then follows the rules, even when an exception might look better in a single case.

What is the greatest happiness principle?

Mill states it as the view that actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness and wrong as they tend to produce the reverse. Bentham called the same idea the principle of utility or the greatest happiness principle, and it is often summarised as the greatest happiness of the greatest number.

What is the main criticism of utilitarianism?

The best-known objection is that it can justify sacrificing an innocent person if doing so increases total wellbeing, which seems to ignore individual rights. Others say wellbeing cannot be measured or compared, or that the theory demands too much from ordinary people.

How does utilitarianism answer the trolley problem?

A straightforward utilitarian says to divert the trolley, because one death is better than five. Many people also feel that pushing someone off a bridge to stop it is different, and the gap between those reactions is what makes the problem useful for testing the theory. Philippa Foot devised the case in 1967, originally to discuss the doctrine of double effect.

Hear Bentham, Kant, Aristotle and the trolley problem as short narrated stories. Download Chunks free on iOS and Android.