What Is Machiavellianism?
Machiavellianism has two related meanings: in politics, the approach to power in Niccolò Machiavelli's The Prince, where rulers judge actions by whether they win and hold power; in psychology, a personality trait marked by manipulation, cynicism and a focus on self-interest.
Also searched as: machiavellianism meaning, what is machiavellianism, machiavellian personality, machiavellianism psychology, dark triad, mach-iv scale
Last updated:
Quick summary
- Political sense: Machiavelli (1469-1527) wrote The Prince in 1513 as advice to a ruler. It treats politics as it is practised, not as moralists wish it were.
- Psychological sense: Richard Christie and Florence Geis built a questionnaire in the 1960s (the Mach scales, published in Studies in Machiavellianism, 1970) to measure how far people hold manipulative, cynical views.
- Machiavellianism is one of the three Dark Triad traits named by Delroy Paulhus and Kevin Williams in 2002, alongside narcissism and psychopathy.
- It is a personality dimension, not a mental illness or a diagnosis.
- The two senses are linked by the name only. Christie and Geis took their questionnaire items from Machiavelli's writings, but Machiavelli himself was a civil servant and republican theorist, not a person with this trait.
- Chunks tells Machiavelli's story, with the context behind The Prince, as a short narrated story.
Machiavellianism in politics: what The Prince argues
Machiavelli wrote for a ruler who had to keep power in an unstable Italy. His central claim is that a prince who always behaves by the ideal of a good man will be ruined among people who are not good. A ruler must therefore learn “how not to be good” when necessary (chapter 15) and judge by results. In chapter 18 he says that if a prince wins and holds his state, his means will always be judged honourable.
Several ideas recur.
- Virtù and fortuna. Skill and force of character (virtù) against luck (fortuna). A prince cannot control luck but can prepare for it.
- Fear and love. In chapter 17 he argues it is safer to be feared than loved if you cannot be both, while warning that a prince must avoid being hated.
- Appearances. A ruler should seem merciful, faithful and religious, and be ready to act otherwise when required (chapter 18).
- Cesare Borgia as a case study. Chapter 7 holds up Borgia as a model of how to win a state through others’ arms and fortune, and why he finally failed.
The popular summary, “the end justifies the means”, is not a line in the book, although chapter 18 comes close to the idea. Machiavelli’s other major work, the Discourses on Livy, shows him praising republics, which makes him harder to read as simply an apologist for tyranny.
Machiavellianism in psychology: the personality trait
In 1970 the psychologists Richard Christie and Florence Geis published Studies in Machiavellianism, describing a questionnaire built from statements in Machiavelli’s writings. The best-known version is the 20-item Mach-IV scale. People rate how far they agree with statements about whether it pays to flatter, bend the truth or trust others. High scorers tend to hold a cynical view of human nature, to treat morality as flexible and to use manipulation when it helps them.
In their laboratory studies, high scorers did best in face-to-face situations that were loosely structured and emotionally charged, where there was room to improvise. In structured settings the advantage faded. A 2012 meta-analysis by Ernest O’Boyle and colleagues (Journal of Applied Psychology) linked high Machiavellianism with more counterproductive work behaviour and lower job performance, so it is not a reliable predictor of success.
In 2002 Delroy Paulhus and Kevin Williams grouped Machiavellianism with narcissism and subclinical psychopathy as the Dark Triad. The three overlap, as all involve some callousness, but they are distinct. Narcissism centres on admiration and entitlement, psychopathy on impulsivity and lack of empathy, and Machiavellianism on calculation and strategic manipulation. All three are traits that everyone has to some degree, not labels for a small group of people.
Origin of the word and key thinkers
Niccolò Machiavelli served the Florentine Republic as a diplomat and official in its Second Chancery from 1498. When the Medici returned to power in 1512 he lost his post, and he was imprisoned and tortured in 1513 on suspicion of joining a plot, though he was released. Retired to his farm outside Florence, he wrote The Prince that year and dedicated it to a Medici, Lorenzo di Piero de’ Medici. It circulated in manuscript and was printed in 1532, five years after his death. Hear the story in Machiavelli and The Prince.
The book shocked readers quickly. The French Huguenot Innocent Gentillet attacked it in 1576, and the English stage was full of “Machiavels”, villains who stood for cunning and betrayal. Francis Bacon took a different line and praised Machiavelli for writing about what people do rather than what they ought to do. In the Social Contract Jean-Jacques Rousseau suggested that The Prince was really a lesson to the people about how rulers behave, a reading some scholars still debate.
The word “Machiavellian” thus came to mean cunning and unscrupulous long before psychology adopted it. In the 1960s Christie and Geis borrowed the name for a trait. Paulhus and Williams then made it one of the three Dark Triad personality traits in 2002.
- Niccolò Machiavelli1469-1527Florentine official and political theorist. Author of The Prince (written 1513, printed 1532) and the Discourses on Livy.
- Innocent Gentilletdied 1588French Huguenot jurist whose Anti-Machiavel (1576) did much to fix Machiavelli's reputation as a teacher of evil.
- Francis Bacon1561-1626Praised Machiavelli for describing what people actually do rather than what they ought to do.
- Jean-Jacques Rousseau1712-1778Read The Prince as a lesson to the people about how rulers behave, in the Social Contract.
- Richard Christie and Florence Geis1960s-70sPsychologists who built the Mach scales and published Studies in Machiavellianism (1970).
- Delroy Paulhus and Kevin Williams2002Named the Dark Triad of narcissism, Machiavellianism and psychopathy in a 2002 paper in the Journal of Research in Personality.
Common misunderstandings
- “Machiavelli said the end justifies the means”
- Those words are not in The Prince. Chapter 18 says that a prince who wins and keeps his state will have his means judged honourable, which is an observation about how people judge, not a recommendation of anything goes. He also warns against cruelty that makes a ruler hated.
- “Machiavelli was himself a Machiavellian schemer”
- He was a civil servant who lost his post and was tortured, and the Discourses on Livy argue for republican government. The personality trait borrows his name, but it says little about him.
- “Machiavellianism is a mental illness, or the same as psychopathy”
- It is a personality trait, one of the Dark Triad. It overlaps with psychopathy and narcissism but is distinct, and scoring high is not a diagnosis. An online quiz cannot tell you whether someone has a disorder.
- “People high in Machiavellianism always get ahead”
- Christie and Geis found they did well in some settings, mainly loose, face-to-face ones. A 2012 meta-analysis (O’Boyle et al., Journal of Applied Psychology) links the trait to more counterproductive work behaviour and lower job performance, and does not show it makes people reliably successful.
Spotting and handling Machiavellian behaviour
You cannot diagnose anyone from outside, and the trait sits on a spectrum. These are sensible habits when someone’s behaviour looks calculating.
- Describe behaviour, not character. “She told two of us different things” is something you can check. “She is a Machiavellian” is a label you cannot.
- Check what is said against what is done. Consistent gaps between the two over time are more informative than one incident.
- Get agreements in writing. Clear, shared records leave less room to shift ground.
- Read The Prince for what it is. Machiavelli’s analysis of how power works is useful for understanding office politics, and it is not a manual to follow.
If you are dealing with manipulation or coercive control in a relationship or workplace, speak to a professional or a support service rather than relying on a personality label.
Frequently asked questions
What is Machiavellianism in simple terms?
It has two meanings. In politics it is the approach to power in Niccolò Machiavelli's The Prince, which treats politics as practised and judges rulers by results. In psychology it is a personality trait marked by manipulation, cynicism and a focus on self-interest.
What does Machiavellian mean as a personality trait?
A Machiavellian personality is one that is strategic, cynical about other people and willing to manipulate or bend the truth to get what it wants. The trait is measured by scales such as the Mach-IV, created by Richard Christie and Florence Geis, and is one of the three Dark Triad traits.
What is the Dark Triad?
The Dark Triad is a set of three related personality traits: narcissism, Machiavellianism and psychopathy, named by Delroy Paulhus and Kevin Williams in a 2002 paper. The traits overlap but are distinct, and everyone scores somewhere on each of them.
Is Machiavellianism a mental illness?
No. It is a personality trait on a spectrum and not a diagnosis. It overlaps with psychopathy and narcissism but is not a clinical condition, and an online quiz cannot diagnose anyone.
What is the Mach-IV scale?
The Mach-IV is a 20-item questionnaire developed by Richard Christie and Florence Geis in the 1960s and described in their 1970 book Studies in Machiavellianism. Its statements, drawn from Machiavelli's writings, ask how far people agree with manipulative and cynical views of human nature.
Did Machiavelli really say the end justifies the means?
No. The phrase is not in The Prince. In chapter 18 Machiavelli says that if a prince conquers and maintains his state, his means will always be judged honourable, which describes how people judge rulers and is not a general rule of conduct.
When was The Prince written and published?
Machiavelli wrote The Prince in 1513 and dedicated it to Lorenzo di Piero de' Medici. It circulated in manuscript and was first printed in 1532, after his death in 1527.
Stories on Machiavellianism
Each is a narrated chapter you can read or listen to in 5–10 minutes.
Thinkers and character cards
Related guides
Keep exploring
Hear Machiavelli and the thinkers around him as short narrated stories. Download Chunks free on iOS and Android.