Skip to content

The Dichotomy of Control: What It Means and How to Use It

TL;DR: The dichotomy of control is the Stoic idea that some things are up to you (your judgements, choices and efforts) and some are not (your body, reputation, other people, and outcomes). It opens Epictetus's Enchiridion and underlies most Stoic practice. The aim is not to care less but to aim your effort where it can work. Below: what Epictetus actually wrote, an everyday example, the common objections, and six exercises you can start today.

What is the dichotomy of control?

The dichotomy of control is the Stoic distinction between what is "up to us" and what is "not up to us". It sorts everything you might care about into two groups and tells you to spend your energy on the first.

It is often taught as the first lesson of Stoicism, because every other Stoic exercise (accepting setbacks, handling insults, facing death) is an application of it. In fact it is the opening sentence of the Enchiridion, the short handbook compiled from the teachings of Epictetus.

What did Epictetus actually say?

The Enchiridion ("handbook") begins with the claim that some things are up to us and some are not (1.1). Epictetus then lists them.

Up to us (eph' hēmin) Not up to us (ouk eph' hēmin)
Judgement or opinion Our body
Impulse (what we choose to pursue) Our property
Desire Reputation
Aversion (what we choose to avoid) Public office and position
In a word, whatever is our own doing In a word, whatever is not our own doing

Epictetus draws consequences straight away (Enchiridion 1.2-5). Things up to us are by nature free, unhindered and unobstructed; things not up to us are weak, slavish, hindered and belong to others. If you mistake the second group for your own, you will be thwarted, upset and blame gods and people. If you treat only what is yours as yours, no one can compel you, no one can hinder you, and you will have no enemy, since no one can harm you.

He then gives a practical instruction (1.5): train yourself to say to every troubling impression, "You are an impression, and not at all what you appear to be." Then test it by your rules, and first by this one: does it concern what is up to me, or not? If it is not up to me, then it is nothing to me.

Epictetus, born a slave, banished by an emperor and living in exile in Nicopolis, was not talking from a comfortable position. For his life, see our summary of the Discourses and Enchiridion.

A worked example

Suppose you are preparing for an important job interview.

  • Up to you: how well you prepare, your honesty, how you treat the interviewer, whether you arrive on time, how you respond to a hard question.
  • Not up to you: whether the other candidates are stronger, the interviewer's mood, the budget, whether the role is quietly promised to someone else, the final decision.

The Stoic advice is not "don't care about the job". It is to put your full effort into the first list, and then, once you have done that, to let the second list go. If you get the job, good. If not, you have lost nothing that was truly yours: your preparation, effort and conduct were yours, and they remain.

The ancient Stoics used an image for this. In Cicero's On Ends (3.22), the Stoic spokesman Cato describes an archer who does everything in his power to shoot straight. Hitting the target is what he aims at, but success as an archer lies in the shooting, not in whether the target is struck. The outcome is "preferred" but not under his command.

Where does the dichotomy come from?

Epictetus gave it its sharpest form, but the idea runs through earlier Stoicism. Chrysippus, the third head of the Stoic school, offered an analogy that appears in Cicero's On Fate (41-43) and in Aulus Gellius (Attic Nights 7.2): if you push a cylinder, the push starts it rolling, but it rolls the way it does because of its own shape. In the same way, impressions from outside prompt us, but the response is ours. That is the point of the dichotomy: the stimulus is not up to you; the assent is.

Marcus Aurelius, writing for himself, applies it constantly. In Meditations 8.47 he says that if something external distresses you, the pain is not due to the thing itself but to your estimate of it, which you have the power to revoke at any moment. Seneca makes the same move in many letters, for instance when he says in Letters 13.4 that we suffer more in imagination than in reality.

What does it look like under extreme pressure?

The best-known modern case is James Stockdale, a US Navy pilot shot down over North Vietnam in September 1965 and held as a prisoner of war for around seven and a half years. Stockdale had studied philosophy at Stanford, where his tutor Philip Rhinelander gave him a copy of the Enchiridion, and he later recalled whispering to himself as he parachuted down that he was leaving the world of technology and entering the world of Epictetus. He credited Epictetus with helping him keep his composure, and in 1993 delivered and published an address with the title "Courage Under Fire: Testing Epictetus's Doctrines in a Laboratory of Human Behavior". He received the Medal of Honor in 1976. Chunks tells his story in James Stockdale: Epictetus in a Vietnamese Prison.

Is the dichotomy of control too simple?

It draws real objections, and a fair account should include them.

"Most things are partly in my control." True, and some modern writers say so. William Irvine, in A Guide to the Good Life (2009), proposes a "trichotomy of control": things fully in your control, things partly in your control, and things not at all. For the middle group (winning a match, getting a job) he suggests internalising your goal: set it as doing your best, which is up to you, instead of winning, which is not. That is essentially the archer's reframe above.

"It makes you passive about injustice." Critics say that telling people to focus on their own responses invites quietism. Stoic practice does not say that. Epictetus, Seneca and Marcus were active in public life, and the Stoics counted justice as one of the four virtues. Your actions are up to you, including the action of resisting wrongdoing; what is not up to you is whether you succeed. Seneca's and Epictetus's "reservation" (acting with the proviso "if nothing prevents") is a way of acting fully while holding results lightly (Enchiridion 2; Seneca, On Benefits 4.34).

"My feelings are not really up to me." The Stoics distinguished first movements, such as a flush of fear or anger that arrives before reflection, from the assent that follows. Seneca discusses the involuntary first stirrings in On Anger (2.2-4). You cannot always stop the first jolt, but you can choose whether to agree with it.

"Is there any evidence it works?" Ancient Stoicism helped inspire modern cognitive therapy. Albert Ellis, who developed rational emotive behaviour therapy in the mid-1950s, quoted Epictetus's idea (Enchiridion 5) that people are disturbed by their judgements about things, not by the things themselves, and Aaron Beck's team later wrote that the philosophical origins of cognitive therapy can be traced back to the Stoics. That is a historical link, not proof that the dichotomy itself has been tested. The best-known studies of Stoic-style programmes, the Stoic Week reports, are uncontrolled before-and-after surveys of self-selected volunteers, and many did not complete the follow-up survey, so treat claims of large effects with caution.

A related point: the dichotomy is not the same as the Serenity Prayer, which is associated with Reinhold Niebuhr (first recorded in print in 1933, with its authorship disputed), though the two are close. The prayer asks for wisdom to know the difference. The Stoics give a method for finding it.

Six exercises to practise the dichotomy of control

  1. Two columns. When something is worrying you, draw two columns, "mine" and "not mine". Write every element of the situation in one or the other. Circle one thing in "mine" that you will do today. This is the most direct version of the Enchiridion.
  2. Speak to the impression. When you feel a surge of anger or anxiety, say to it, "You are an impression, not the thing itself." Then ask the question: is this up to me? (Enchiridion 1.5.) It is deliberately simple.
  3. Rewrite the goal. For any goal with an uncertain outcome, rewrite it so that it describes your effort, not the result. "Get the promotion" becomes "do excellent work on the project and ask for feedback". This follows Cicero's archer and Irvine's internalisation.
  4. The evening review. At night, ask where you spent today's energy: on mine or not mine? Seneca describes the Stoic Sextius doing a nightly review of this kind in On Anger 3.36. Note one situation you will handle differently tomorrow.
  5. Rehearse in advance. Before a stressful event, imagine it going badly and ask what is still up to you in that case. This is the premeditatio malorum ("rehearsal of misfortunes") that Seneca recommends, for instance in Letters 91 and 107. It removes the surprise and focuses attention on your response.
  6. Judge by conduct. At the end of a day, assess yourself by what you did, not by what happened. If you did what was yours to do, count it as a good day even if the result was bad. This is the part that takes longest to learn.

If you want to connect this to the other Stoic exercises, amor fati deals with what to do after the sorting, and memento mori uses the same logic about time. For the original lines, see 50+ Stoic Quotes With Sources.

Common mistakes

  • Treating "not up to me" as "not my problem". The dichotomy tells you where to spend effort, not what to stop caring about.
  • Sorting emotions into the wrong column. Your first reaction is not fully up to you, but your agreement with it is.
  • Using it to excuse inaction. If something is up to you, the dichotomy says to act on it.
  • Dropping other people. Epictetus says other people's actions are not up to you, but how you treat them is. Stoic ethics includes duties to family, friends and community.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the dichotomy of control in simple terms?

It is the Stoic habit of dividing what you face into things that are up to you (your judgements, choices and effort) and things that are not (other people, outcomes, your reputation and your body), and focusing on the first.

Who came up with the dichotomy of control?

The Stoics developed it, and Epictetus stated it most clearly in the opening of the Enchiridion: "Some things are up to us and some are not". Marcus Aurelius and Seneca apply it throughout their writing, though they do not give it the same label.

Is your body under your control, according to the Stoics?

No. Epictetus lists the body among things not up to us, together with property, reputation and office (Enchiridion 1.1). You can look after it, but you cannot guarantee health or survival. That fits with the Stoic practice of preparing for loss and illness.

Is the dichotomy of control the same as the Serenity Prayer?

They are close in spirit. Both ask you to separate what can be changed from what cannot. The Serenity Prayer is a request; the Stoic dichotomy is a method with specific exercises.

What is the trichotomy of control?

It is a refinement proposed by William Irvine in A Guide to the Good Life. It adds a middle category, things you partly control, and suggests setting goals in terms of your own effort, not the outcome.

How do I use the dichotomy of control at work?

Write down the parts of a project that are yours (your preparation, communication and quality of work), do those well, and let go of reactions you cannot predict. The two-columns and rewrite-the-goal exercises above are designed for this.

Learning more

Stoicism is easiest to absorb through lives that tested it. Chunks tells those lives as short narrated stories, with a free tier and no ads, including Epictetus, Seneca and Marcus Aurelius, grouped in a Stoics pack. For the whole system, start with What Is Stoicism?, and our Stoic apps guide covers tools for daily practice.

Andy Shephard, Founder of Chunks

Andy Shephard

Founder of Chunks Microlearning. Software engineer with 15 years of experience.

Start learning today

In just minutes, you can uncover something new and fascinating — with content tailored to spark your curiosity and match your interests.